Health Policy Insight
Healthcare management online analysis and intelligence
The home of UK health policy

HPI Content

Editor's blog Wednesday 19 January 2011: Beginnings, endings and gravity talking

Publish Date/Time: 
01/19/2011 - 08:52

Today it begins.

Today the NHS faces a fascinatingly undeveloped, electorally-unpromised and fundamental overhaul.

Today we start the legislative move from a system with hundreds of statutory commissioning organisations with accountable officers, working to national standards and regulation and offering patient choice to ... a system with hundreds of statutory commissioning organisations, working to national standards and regulation and offering patient choice.

Mmmm.

Editor’s blog Tuesday 18 January 2011: Damning PFI and commissioning reports out

Publish Date/Time: 
01/18/2011 - 16:21

Politicians can do really good things, we should remember.

And one of the glories of a well-functioning Parliamentary select committee is that it can cut through the ordure-ordure of party-political partisan middle-aged shoutiness, and produce really useful reports on what is happening.

Editor’s blog Monday 17 January 2011: PM David Cameron's RSA speech on public services, reviewed

Publish Date/Time: 
01/17/2011 - 15:21

The full text of PM David Cameron's RSA speech on public services can be found here.

What follows below is the NHS-relevant sections, with some observations about the content in bold.

Editor’s blog Monday 17 January 2011: What is the question that SOS Lansley’s NHS reforms are trying to answer?

Publish Date/Time: 
01/17/2011 - 11:08

A major media offensive is under way to launch NHS Week (as the Downing Street 'media grid' has it.) This is the first step in the effort to tell the story of 'liberating the NHS'.

Policyland is a funny little bubble, and it is probably useful for us to remember that most people don't plough through vast policy documents. So for many people, the news of a vast, whole-scale, whole-system NHS reform throughout this week is going to be the first they have heard about it.

Editor's blog Thursday 13 January 2011: The battalions gear up for uncivil war

Publish Date/Time: 
01/13/2011 - 19:14

Of late, two 20th-century political figures have been much-quoted in regard to NHS reform.

Both men - Stalin and Mao - were highly-effective Communist dictators who also killed a lot of their own people.

Yes, I'm hoping there isn't a subtext too.

Editor's blog Wednesday 12 January 2011: Health and NHS lines from today's PMQs and Monday's urgent question on flu

Publish Date/Time: 
01/12/2011 - 16:20

The NHS lines, Prime Minister’s Questions 12.1.11

Ed Miliband, Leader Of The Opposition: “His health minister (Paul Burstow MP. Lib Dem) said in his surgery, ‘I don’t want you to trust David Cameron – he has values I don’t share’.”

Guest editorial Tuesday 11 January 2011: Just like deja vu all over again?

Publish Date/Time: 
01/11/2011 - 17:00

Irwin Brown of the Socialist Health Association wonders at a fragmented future for the NHS

When the previous Tory government came into power in 1979, they had a clear agenda about changes to public services and they had a hidden agenda that allowed them to weaken the likely centres of opposition to their plans.

They used their state power to reduce the power and role of the trade unions and local government, and they used a variety of means, including the break-up of the council estates, to weaken communities. The Labour opposition was poorly placed to oppose.

The Maynard Doctrine: Does competition work in healthcare?

Publish Date/Time: 
01/11/2011 - 02:19

Professor Alan Maynard wishes you all a Happy New Year, but is basically a realist, and so doesn’t propose to push it. Here he investigates competition and whether it works in healthcare.

Successive governments have become enthusiastic proponents of competition in healthcare in the USA and the UK. The nice issue is whether there is proof that such enthusiasm for and development of competition can be evidenced as having reduced the costs of providing good-quality care patients.